Skip to main content

This site requires you to update your browser. Your browsing experience maybe affected by not having the most up to date version.

We've moved the forum!

Please use for any new questions (announcement).
The forum archive will stick around, but will be read only.

You can also use our Slack channel or StackOverflow to ask for help.
Check out our community overview for more options to contribute.

Forum Module /

Discuss the Forum Module.

Moderators: martimiz, Sean, Ed, biapar, Willr, Ingo, swaiba

Forum Module/MVC/vBulletin

Go to End

4 Posts   9688 Views


Community Member, 2 Posts

11 September 2009 at 4:36pm

Edited: 11/09/2009 4:38pm


I've been looking to at several PHP based bulletin board/message board/forum software and was wondering how the silverstripe forum module compares to vBulletin.

I'm looking for a forum designed using MVC. I've played with vBulletin and found it lacking when it comes to customizing templates since they are stored in a database, and the code is rather messy and its not really intuitive in this regard. Its seems like the code has been massaged/glued together to work. vBulletin does have a vast feature set.

Has anyone used both? Thoughts? Feature wise?



Community Member, 3 Posts

16 September 2009 at 10:59am

If it's just a forum vBulleting would be better than SS in my opinion. But, what are you looking to do as a whole? I mean if you want a site revolving around the forum SS may be better if you don't need to many features in the forum it self.

I would also look at MyBB if it's just a forum ;).


Community Member, 2 Posts

16 September 2009 at 11:38am

Well I basically need the forums to be customized and embedded in the site. The site user login would be shared/the same for the forum (single sign on). What I don't like about vBulletin is that the template code is actually in the database as well as the css, which makes it tedious to edit/preview and integrate.

I'm thinking it was designed that way so the user could roll back to defaults, but I would prefer a templating engine like PHPTal or Smarty built with an MVC framework (Symfony/Zend) to make it easier to customize. CMS would be a plus.

A quick google search points to the RedBB project ( which is based on Zend but I don't think its been released yet.

Maybe there is something available for Ruby. I've been considering learning the language, though the lack of semicolon to terminate the line is a turn off. :/


Community Member, 3 Posts

16 September 2009 at 1:10pm

Yes, but features wise what are you looking for in just the forum?

If you want of a lot of template control SS would be good. But, if you want to use a template system I would even recommend drupal as you well they have smarty template system if you want it.

However their forum is even more basic than SS's.